40 years later: The Fort Worth mansion murders mystery

John McCaa sits down with accused murderer Cullen Davis to discuss the high-profile trial 40 years ago and the unsolved mystery of a murder in his Fort Worth mansion.

Forget O.J., or the Charles Manson case. The real trial of the century took place a lot closer than you think.

Fort Worth’s Cullen Davis was once one of the richest men in America in one of the most high-profile marriages in Texas.

But in one night, he went from wealthy oil baron to accused multi-murderer.

In 1968, Cullen Davis, at the pinnacle of Fort Worth’s social set, married Priscilla. She was pretentious, a penchant for bending the rules of polite society.

With her came three children. The youngest, 12-year-old Andrea, and Jack from her second marriage. Dee came from her first marriage.

But by 1976, Cullen and Priscilla were living under separate roofs -- with other people.

On August 2, the judge in their divorce case dealt Cullen a financial setback.

“Well, I don’t remember the details,” Cullen Davis told News 8 in an extended interview. “Only the bottom line, he increased my wife’s monthly payments somewhat.”

News reports at the time say the payments when up from $3,500 to $5,000 a month. Plus, more than $50,000 for her legal expenses and other bills. 

%INLINE%

That same night, a man wearing a wig, dressed in black, entered Priscilla’s mansion home. The man shot and killed her boyfriend Stan Farr and her daughter Andrea, and wounded Priscilla and a family friend.

Dee Davis, at a friend’s house that night, found a still-distraught Priscilla in the emergency room, whispering, “Dee, Cullen shot me,” according to Davis. She went on to tell her Mother, “okay, I understand, I understand. They’ll get him.”

But Cullen insisted he’d been at the movies that night, alone. He said he saw “Bad News Bears” and ended the night at girlfriend Karen Master's home and not the mansion. The following exchange occurred during our interview:

Cullen Davis: Wasn’t me.

John McCaa: You never had a wig?

Davis: No.

McCaa: Never had any involvement, any kind of plot planned?

Davis:  No. No.

McCaa: You’re absolutely, 100 percent not guilty of this.

Davis: That’s absolutely, 100 percent right.

Prosecutors, though, believed they had their man.

Publicity moved the trial for the murder of Andrea to Amarillo.

Cullen’s lead attorney, Houston’s Richard “Racehorse” Haynes, went after Priscilla. He made allegations of drug use and wild sex parties.

%INLINE%

“They were so consumed with my mother’s appearance, her bad girl image…,” he said. “And hey, guess what? It wasn’t about her. It was about a 12-year-old child that was murdered.”

But the jury found Cullen Davis not guilty. He was elated.

“I can’t tell you how good it feels because I've been in there 15 months fighting this thing,” he said.

Lawyer Racehorse Haynes was also happy with the verdict at the time.

“Looks like I'm out of a job I guess. I got to go to work,” he told reporters at the time. “I guess I'll start looking for a job... I don’t know where I'll start looking but I'll look somewhere.”

%INLINE%

He wouldn’t be out of work for long. A year later, Haynes was back in court, defending Cullen again, after undercover film emerged allegedly showing Cullen Davis in short sleeves secretly paying a man $25,000 for a photograph of the murdered judge in his divorce case. He promised to pay more to have Priscilla and others killed.

Cullen claimed he was there helping the FBI after a friend of Priscilla’s approached him with the plot. Unbeknownst to Cullen, it was all staged. The judge posed for the photo.

%INLINE%

To this day, despite the videotape, despite the $25,000 he gave, Cullen Davis insists he was set up. But he has forgotten some of the specifics about what occurred at the time.

For example, I asked, “what was the $25,000 for?” He answered, “I don’t remember. That was – that’s why I said, there was something about the – the $25,000, but I don’t – I don’t remember how that came into play.”

At the trial in Houston, they conceded Cullen was on the videotape, but said he was assisting investigators. He says the jury believed him.

“The jury listened to those tapes real closely, and they said, “Wait a minute, Cullen’s telling the truth, here,” he said.

Certainly some of the jury did. It deadlocked 8-to-4 to convict. The judge declared a mistrial. But for Cullen Davis, the ruling was clear: he was and is innocent.

A born-again Christian now, forgiveness has taken on new meaning for Cullen Davis. In an hour-long interview, he told News 8, he has forgiven all of the people who have accused him falsely.

Some of them have forgiven him, but not Dee Davis.

“You have to acknowledge and admit you’re wrong to ask for that forgiveness,” she said. “And so far, I haven’t heard him claim any kind of responsibility for anything.”

But Cullen insists it is not about any guilt, but submission to being born again. Dee Davis gets that, but while Cullen may be at peace, questions linger for her.

“Who killed my sister then?,” she asked. “If Cullen Davis didn’t do it, then who did it?”

%INLINE%

For years, a report has circulated that the night of the mansion murders, “Bad News Bears” was not playing at the theater where Davis insists he saw it.

If true, it was never brought up in the criminal trials.

Cullen Davis’ wife Karen passed away just a few weeks ago.

Priscilla Davis died of cancer in 2001.

To this day, Cullen Davis insists he’s innocent.

Copyright 2016 WFAA


JOIN THE CONVERSATION

To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the
Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Leave a Comment